Hummer
Car manufacturer and insurers disputed personal-use claim
Settlement: | Defense | |
Case Type: | Lemon Law. Motor Vehicle - Lemon Law. Appeals | |
Case: | General Motors Corporation v. Thomas J. Pira and Claudia Plra. No. 9328/06 | |
Venue: | Suffolk Supreme, NY | |
Judge: | Gary J. Weber | |
Date: | Monday, August 07, 2006 | |
Plaintiff Attorney(s): | Anthony T. Ballato; Massapequa. NY, for Thomas J. Pira, Claudia Pira | |
Defendant Attorney(s): | Justin E. Proper; The Rose Law Firm, PLLC; Albany, NY, for General Motors Corp. | |
Facts: | On Jan. 6, 2006, plaintiff General Motors Corp. lost an "arbitration proceeding that was based on the New Car Lemon Law, General Business law article 11-A. § 198·a. As a result, General Motors was ordered to repay $49,453 to Claudia and Thomas Pira, in exchange for the return of the Piras ' 2003 Hummer," General Motors vehicle. The Piras had claimed that the Hummer's climate control blew hot air Into the vehicle's passenger compartment when it should have been providing cool air. They claimed that the vehicle was returned to the dealer on four or more occasions for repair, but that the problem was never resolved. They attempted to return the vehicle, but it was refused by General Motors. The Piras sought recovery via application of the Lemon Law. They claimed that the vehicle's condition constituted a violation of the Lemon Law. which specifies that a vehicle's first 24 months and/or 18,000 miles should not include more than four repair attempts and/or 30 days of repair shop time. Arbitrator Gerald Love found for the Piras and awarded a refund of the Hummer's $49,453 purchase price. General Motors filed a Lemon Law Article 75 Appeal (CPLR 7511), seeking to vacate the arbitrator's decision. It alleged that the Lemon Law did not apply because the Piras were using the Hummer for business purposes. PIaintiff's counsel, claimed that New York's Lemon Law is only for the benefit or consumers' "personal use" and that the Piras actually used the vehicle for predominantly business and not for personal use, based on depreciation alleged in their tax returns. It contended that the Consumer statute applies to the "personal use" of a vehicle and that it disqualifies relief via the Lemon Law if the primary use, or more than 50% of its use, is not for personal use. The Piras acknowledged that the Hummer is occasionally used for business purposes, but they contended that the vehicle was primarily used for personal reasons. They further, acknowledged that the vehicle was used for appraisals, but they contended that such activity did not constitute "business use." | |
Injury: | General Motors sought to deny the Piras ' recovery of $49.453, the amount awarded in the Lemon Law arbitration. The Piras counterclaimed for recovery of attorney fees. | |
Verdict: | Judge Gary Weber found for the defense, though he denied the Plras ' attempt to recover attorney fees. EDITOR'S COMMENTS: This report Is based on in formation that was provided by defense counsel. Plaintiff's counsel did not respond to the reporter's phone call. |
Anthony T. Ballato, Esq. on Auto Fraud and NY Lemon Law Part 1 and 2
Lemon Law Cases
- Steven V. v. General Motors
- Singh, R. v. General Motors LLC
- Rachel P. v. FCA US LLC
- Brian M. v. Audi of America, LLC
- Karan L. v. Harley Davidson Motor Co.
- Daniel C. vs. Harley Davidson
- Michael A. v. FCA US LLC
- Baumgardt, Jean A. V. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- David F. v. Volkswagen of America Inc.
- Shannon O. v. FCA US LLC
- Ian B. v. Ford
- Stephen Fisher v. Ford
- P. R. v. JJM Automotive LLC d/b/a Empire Chrysler Doge Ram of West Islip
- Kennedy, S&W v. General Motors LLC
- Rafael Gonzalez v. Volvo Cars of North America
- Jose Franceschi v. Chevrolet / General Motors, LLC
- Egbert, Peter v. Alfa Romeo / FCA
- Louis Q. v. Porsche Cars of North America
- Joshua Caspi v. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- Jasleen Rayano v. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- Consumer B. versus BMW of North America, LLC
- Baumgardt v. Jaguar Land Rover North America LLC
- Jaqueline Cuellar v. Chevrolet / General Motors LLC
- Richard Mills v. Chevrolet / General Motors, LLC
- Gregory Lehecka v GM LLC
- Mary Grace McAllister Davis v. Chevrolet / General Motors
- Francine Kaczor v. Audi of America
- Elisabeth Gagliano v. FCA US LLC / Jeep
- Gary Fish v. GMC
- Alan R Versus BMW of North America, Inc.
- Lawrence Sparks v. Audi of America
- Richard and MaryJo Graffeo v. Audi of America
- Louis DeRose v. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- Brian Stefanovic v. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- Jeremy Maswary v. Ford Motor Company
- Thomas Arceri v. FCA US LLC
- Allison Quinto v. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- William and Barbara Ahlers v. Subaru of America, Inc.
- Laurie Golowach v. General Motors Corporation
- Howard Z. v. Maserati
- Maryanne & Michael Hinchy v. Nissan North America
- David Casamento and Andrew Berends v. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- Nabieva Madina v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC
- Kathleen Friedman v. Audi of America
- Bentley, McLaren, BMW and Mini Cooper Vehicles
- Kevin Aldrich v. FCA US LLC
- Robert Rapisarda v. FCA US LLC
- Oscar Deco, Inc. / Aida Calderon v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC
- Peter Arner v. Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
- Peter Cardone v. Jeep / FCA US LLC
- Paulo Rodriguez Arias v. Chevrolet Motor Division
- Rafael Gonzalez v. Volvo Cars of North America
- Demetrios M. Perdios v. Audi of America
- Auto Dealer Fraud / Deceptive Trade Practices Alleged And Used Lemon Vehicle
- Lemon Law / New Car Purchase
- Used Car Purchase / New Car Lemon Law
- Lemon Law / New Car Lease
- Lemon Law New Car Purchase
- BMW Auto Dealer Fraud Deceptive Trade Practices
- Chevrolet Tahoe New Car Purchase Lemon Law
- General Motors Lemon Law New Car Purchase
- Lemon Law New Car Lease
- Mazda Used Car Purchase Lemon Law
- Nissan Infinity New Car Lease Purchase Lemon Law
- Nissan Maxima New Car Purchase Lemon Law
- Porshe Used Car Repurchase Lemon Law
- Volvo Used Car Lemon Law
- Jeep Renegade
- Chevrolet Camaro
- Acura MDX
- Jeep Grand Cherokee
- Ford Escape
- Honda Pilot
- Lexus LX570
- Toyota Rav 4
- Dodge Challenger
- Hyundai Tucson
- Chevrolet Tahoe Truck
- Volkswagen Passat
- Dodge Charger
- Jeep Renegade
- Jeep Grand Cherokee
- Chevrolet Camaro
- Mercedes GLA45
- Jeep Grand Cherokee
- Honda CRV-EXL
- Porsche Carrera Turbo
- Volkswagen Tiguan
- Audi A8
- Chevrolet Tahoe Truck
- Dodge Ram 2500 SLT truck
- Audi S4 Sedan
- Hyundai Tucson
- Lexus ES350
- Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland
- Infiniti QX56 SUV
- McLaren MP4-12C
- Maserati Ghibli
- Maserati GT Sport
- Ford F350 Diesel Pick-up Truck
- Dodge Ram 2500 Full Refund
- Jeep Grand Cherokee
- Audi S4
- Ford Edge
- Subaru Outback
- Audi TT Convertible
- Ford Mustang Saleen S281
- Chevrolet Cruze Turbo Diesel
- Hyundai Genesis
- Volkswagen Passat
- Chrysler Eagle
- Chrysler Cross-Fire
- Volkswagen Toureg
- Kawasaki Motorcyle
- Bentley
- Cadillac Escalade
- Cadillac STS Sedan
- Cadillac XLR Convertible Roadster
- Chevrolet Camaro
- Chevrolet Corvette
- Chevy Equinox
- Dodge Intrepid
- Ford Cougar
- Ford Escape
- Ford Expedition
- Ford F350 Pickup Truck
- Ford Windstar
- Ford Windstar
- Ford Windstar
- General Motors
- General Motors GMC Acadia
- Hummer
- Infiniti G35 Sport Sedan
- Infiniti Q45
- Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland
- Kia Sephia
- Land Rover Discovery
- Lexus SC430
- Nissan Maxima
- Audi A6 Sedan
- Nissan Maxima
- Nissan Quest
- Porsche Cayenne
- Volkswagen Jetta
- Volkswagen Passat
- Volkswagen Touareg